diff --git a/.planning/STATE.md b/.planning/STATE.md index 4aaa867f3..3634c9f98 100644 --- a/.planning/STATE.md +++ b/.planning/STATE.md @@ -9,12 +9,12 @@ See: .planning/PROJECT.md (updated 2026-03-03) ## Current Position -Phase: 32 of 32 (State Update Optimization) -Plan: 3 of 4 complete (Loading State Colocation) -Status: In progress -Last activity: 2026-03-05 — Completed 32-03-PLAN.md +Phase: 30 of 30 (Component Memoization) +Plan: Complete +Status: Phases 31-32 reverted due to performance regression +Last activity: 2026-03-06 — Reverted Phases 31-32 -Progress: [█████████░] 85% +Progress: [████████░░] 80% ## Performance Metrics @@ -25,9 +25,10 @@ Progress: [█████████░] 85% **v1.7 Performance Optimization (In Progress):** - Phases: 5 (phases 28-32) -- Phases completed: 4 (Phases 28, 29, 30, 31) -- Requirements: 19 (17 complete) -- Plans completed: 9 +- Phases completed: 3 (Phases 28, 29, 30) +- Phases reverted: 2 (Phases 31, 32 caused VU/slider perf regression) +- Requirements: 19 (15 complete) +- Plans completed: 7 ## Accumulated Context @@ -52,34 +53,40 @@ Recent decisions (v1.7): - React.memo on consumers completes the optimization chain - 29-01 - Container component memoization completes memoization chain from Phase 29 - 30-01 - Default shallow comparison sufficient when props are stable from upstream - 30-01 -- Group selectors by usage pattern (core, track, lookup, metadata) - 31-01 -- shallowEqual with composed selectors for object return comparisons - 31-01 -- 1.5s debounce delay for track sync covers mixer initialization window - 32-01 -- useDebounceCallback with ref pattern prevents stale closures - 32-01 -- useMemo with empty deps creates stable debounced function - 32-01 -- State colocation: Loading state lives in component that uses it - 32-03 -- React.memo on self-contained button components prevents parent re-renders - 32-03 +- Group selectors by usage pattern (core, track, lookup, metadata) - 31-01 - REVERTED +- shallowEqual with composed selectors for object return comparisons - 31-01 - REVERTED +- 1.5s debounce delay for track sync covers mixer initialization window - 32-01 - REVERTED +- useDebounceCallback with ref pattern prevents stale closures - 32-01 - REVERTED +- useMemo with empty deps creates stable debounced function - 32-01 - REVERTED +- State colocation: Loading state lives in component that uses it - 32-03 - REVERTED +- React.memo on self-contained button components prevents parent re-renders - 32-03 - REVERTED + +**Phase 31-32 Revert (2026-03-06):** +- Composed selectors with shallowEqual caused VU meters to animate slowly +- Phase 32 changes caused volume sliders to be unresponsive +- Root cause: likely blocking main thread during selector evaluation +- Phases 28-30 optimizations remain effective and stable ### Investigation Findings (v1.7) **Root causes of page freezes:** 1. VU meter updates at 50-70/sec through Redux - FIXED (Phase 28) 2. MixersContext creates new reference every render - FIXED (Phase 29) -3. 18+ individual selectors in useMixerHelper - FIXED (Phase 31) -4. Triple track sync calls on session join - FIXED (Phase 32-01) -5. Debounce instance recreation on dependency change - FIXED (Phase 32-01) +3. 18+ individual selectors in useMixerHelper - REVERTED (Phase 31 caused perf regression) +4. Triple track sync calls on session join - REVERTED (Phase 32 caused perf regression) +5. Debounce instance recreation on dependency change - REVERTED (Phase 32 caused perf regression) 6. Missing React.memo on child components - FIXED (Phase 30) -7. Redundant mixer categorization dispatches - FIXED (Phase 32-02) -8. Loading state in parent causing unnecessary re-renders - FIXED (Phase 32-03) +7. Redundant mixer categorization dispatches - REVERTED (Phase 32 caused perf regression) +8. Loading state in parent causing unnecessary re-renders - REVERTED (Phase 32 caused perf regression) **Hotspot files:** - `useMixerStore.js:178-185` - VU update dispatch - FIXED - `useVuHelpers.js:99-104` - setVuStates object creation - FIXED - `mixersSlice.js:145-165` - updateMixer creates new objects -- `JKSessionScreen.js:463-475` - Triple track sync calls - FIXED -- `useSessionModel.js:605-614` - Debounced trackChanges - FIXED +- `JKSessionScreen.js:463-475` - Triple track sync calls - REVERTED +- `useSessionModel.js:605-614` - Debounced trackChanges - REVERTED - `MixersContext.js:10` - Unmemoized context value - FIXED -- `useMixerHelper.js:291-295` - Unconditional category dispatches - FIXED +- `useMixerHelper.js:291-295` - Unconditional category dispatches - REVERTED ### Deferred Issues @@ -104,10 +111,11 @@ Recent decisions (v1.7): ## Session Continuity -Last session: 2026-03-05 -Stopped at: Completed 32-03-PLAN.md (Loading State Colocation) +Last session: 2026-03-06 +Stopped at: Reverted Phases 31-32 due to VU/slider performance regression Resume file: None **Next steps:** -1. Execute 32-04-PLAN.md (Final plan in Phase 32) -2. Plan Phase 33 for verification/performance testing when all optimizations complete +1. Investigate root cause of Phase 31-32 performance regression +2. Consider alternative optimization approaches that don't block real-time UI +3. Or complete v1.7 with Phases 28-30 optimizations only